There are Two People in this Photo

Karin Kallmaker LIFE + STYLE

I’ve seen a lot of (hilarious and thoughtful and mean and deserving) commentary about the Miley Cyrus VMA performance that tried to be performance art a la Madonna or Lady Gaga and instead was a train wreck of bad trashy sexual dancing with oversized children’s toys that sent a strange and unsettling message. It was supposed to shock and it did. Time will tell if it’s in the way that Cyrus and her handlers intended.

To those who are particularly outraged at the sexually charged part of Cyrus’s performance, heaping on lots of disgust for her tongue-wagging, butt-grinding and fetish attire as if she’s 13 and not 20, how about some shame for 36-year old Robin Thicke? Why aren’t his taste, artistic integrity and morals up for ridicule?

Did Cyrus rub a foam finger on her crotch? Yes she did. Did I find it gross? Yes I did. Did Michael Jackson grab his crotch when he sang? Yes he did. Did I find it gross? Yes I did.

I would guess that in the last 24 hours there has been more condemnation for crotch-fondling heaped on Cyrus, however, than on Jackson in total of all his years of performing. One could argue that in Jackson’s case he had talent and Cyrus not so much, but low-talent male performers crotch grab on the VMAs as well and it’s not a national headline.

That the performance was tacky and tasteless is, to me, undeniable.  But there’s a double standard in criticism of art and I’m pointing it out. Is Cyrus blameless? Of course not. She was the headliner – it was her number. But there are TWO PEOPLE in this photo and only one is being slut shamed and labelled “disgusting,” “desperate,” “disturbing,” and questioned about whether virginity was compromised.

Additional comment: Someone has passed on that it’s reported this segment was suggested by Thicke. So the double standard of the shame game being wholly heaped on Cyrus is even more so. Thicke is a cool bad boy and Cyrus is a disgusting, desperate slut?

Copyrighted material.

Comments 2

  1. I too thought the performance was disgusting and Robin is also to blame. IMHO though I think the reason that such a big deal is being made about it is because no one wants her to grow up. Everyone seems to want her to be Hannah Montana forever. She's 20 now let her grow up and do adult things whether I like them or not. Christina Aguillara (remember the Xtina phase) went through the same criticism, albeit Aguillara has a better voice.

  2. You don't hear or see much being said about Lady Gaga sitting around in a shell bikini, or even half of the things that she has done. I know that there have been other performances by Beyonce, Rihana and others where there were questionable moves on their part but again, no comment or “slut shaming”.. did I get that term correct? where did that term come from.. anyway, I think alot of it is publicity grabbing activity because she has an album ready to release.

Comments are closed.